Welcome to Cagney's Pizza King, a delightful gem nestled in the heart of Shelbyville, Indiana. Located at 33 E Broadway St, this family-friendly pizzeria has quickly become a local favorite for pizza enthusiasts and comfort food lovers alike. With a reputation for great service and a warm atmosphere, Cagney's offers an inviting space to enjoy some of the most delicious pies in town.

The menu is a true celebration of pizza art, featuring specialties that will tease your taste buds and leave you craving more. Take, for example, their Buffalo Chicken Pizza: a sumptuous 14-inch creation topped with tender chicken, melted mozzarella, and spicy wing sauce. Priced at $22.62, this pie is a MUST-TRY for anyone who enjoys a kick of flavor in every slice. If you prefer something a tad different, the Taco Pizza brings a unique twist with taco meat, crisp lettuce, juicy tomatoes, and cheddar cheese, available in sizes for the whole family, from a hearty 7-inch for $11.00 to a generous 16-inch for $31.00. Each bite is a fiesta!

But Cagney's doesn’t stop at pizza—its appetizer selection is equally enticing. The Loaded Potato Skins ($12.38) and Nachos Supreme ($11.38) are perfect for sharing—or indulging solo, depending on your appetite! And if you have kids (or kids-at-heart), the Chicken Dippers and cheesy Breast Sticks are sure to please, showcasing the pizzeria's knack for satisfying everyone.

While customer reviews highlight the fantastic food, they also speak of the excellent service and friendly staff. One happy customer, Mary, praised Cagney's as a hit for her grandkids and appreciated the ease of a dinner that required no cooking. Christi Gadd appreciated the warmth of the staff, although her experience was slightly marred by a raw pizza—though she quickly made it right at home! This shows the commitment to customer satisfaction; mistakes happen, but it's how they are handled that makes a place truly shine. Customers like Joey Glynn and William Hardin echo this sentiment, lauding both the quality of food and the inviting atmosphere.

Cagney's Pizza King is more than just a restaurant; it's a gathering place for families and friends. Whether dining in or grabbing takeout, the aroma of freshly baked pizza and the joyful buzz of conversations will make you feel right at home. It’s where good vibes meet great food—a true pizza kingdom waiting for you to explore.

So next time you're in Shelbyville, drop by Cagney's Pizza King for a slice (or two) of happiness!