Welcome to Cagney's Pizza King, a hidden gem located in the heart of Shelbyville, IN. This cozy establishment serves up a range of specialty pizzas that beckon to be savored. Standouts include their unique BLT Pizza and the zesty Buffalo Chicken Pizza, both available in generous sizes to satisfy any appetite.
The menu doesn't stop at pizzas—try the Chili Nachos or Chicken Dippers for a delightful appetizer before diving into more substantial fare. Cagney's commitment to quality shines through customer favorites like the Deluxe Five Toppings Pizza, catering to diverse tastes and preferences.
With positive feedback highlighting the friendly service and welcoming atmosphere, Cagney's Pizza King isn't just a place to eat; it's an experience. Whether you're dining in or taking out, it's clear that every bite is a step towards pizza perfection. Your taste buds will thank you!
King Pizza
One Topping Cheese Pizza - 7"
US$9.50One Topping Cheese Pizza - 10"
US$12.50One Topping Cheese Pizza - 14"
US$18.88One Topping Cheese Pizza - 16"
US$25.12Deluxe Five Toppings Pizza - 7"
US$12.38Deluxe Five Toppings Pizza - 10"
US$16.50Deluxe Five Toppings Pizza - 14"
US$25.50Deluxe Five Toppings Pizza - 16"
US$34.50Combination Of Two Pizza - 7"
US$10.50Combination Of Two Pizza - 10"
US$13.75Combination Of Two Pizza - 14"
US$20.88Combination Of Two Pizza - 16"
US$27.88Combination Of Three Pizza - 7"
US$11.38Combination Of Three Pizza - 10"
US$15.00Combination Of Three Pizza - 14"
US$22.88Combination Of Three Pizza - 16"
US$30.50 Specialty Pizza
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza - 7"
US$11.00Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza - 10"
US$15.12Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza - 14"
US$22.62Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza - 16"
US$29.62Taco Pizza - 7"
US$11.00Taco Pizza - 10"
US$16.50Taco Pizza - 14"
US$27.50Taco Pizza - 16"
US$31.00BLT Pizza - 7"
US$11.00BLT Pizza - 10"
US$15.12BLT Pizza - 14"
US$22.62BLT Pizza - 16"
US$29.62BBQ Chicken Pizza - 7"
US$11.00BBQ Chicken Pizza - 10"
US$15.12BBQ Chicken Pizza - 14"
US$22.62BBQ Chicken Pizza - 16"
US$29.62Buffalo Chicken Pizza - 7"
US$11.00Buffalo Chicken Pizza - 10"
US$15.12Buffalo Chicken Pizza - 14"
US$22.62Buffalo Chicken Pizza - 16"
US$29.62Hawaiian Pizza - 7"
US$11.00Hawaiian Pizza - 10"
US$15.12Hawaiian Pizza - 14"
US$22.62Hawaiian Pizza - 16"
US$29.62 Appetizers
Chicken Dippers - Appetizer
US$9.62Stuffed Bread Sticks - Appetizer
US$8.62Bread Sticks - 3 Pieces
US$7.12Bread Sticks - Family
US$13.12Nachos - Appetizer
US$7.62Chili Nachos - Appetizer
US$8.12Mozzarella Sticks - Appetizer
US$9.38Fried Pickles - Appetizer
US$9.12Pepper Cheese Cubes - Appetizer
US$9.38Garlic Bread - 1/2
US$2.12Garlic Bread - Whole
US$3.25Cheese Bread - 1/2
US$3.75Cheese Bread - Whole
US$6.88French Fries - Appetizer
US$4.12Loaded French Fries - Appetizer
US$8.75Potato Skins - Appetizer
US$10.62Loaded Potato Skins - Appetizer
US$12.38Nachos Supreme - Appetizer
US$11.38Soup Of The Day - Cup
US$3.50Soup Of The Day - Bowl
US$4.50 Salads
Toss Salad - Salad
US$4.12Toss Salad With Cheddar Cheese - Salad
US$5.12Sicilian Salad - Junior
US$9.25Sicilian Salad - Large
US$12.12Taco Salad - Salad
US$12.12Southwest Grilled Chicken Salad - Small
US$9.25Southwest Grilled Chicken Salad - Large
US$12.12Crispy Chicken Caesar Salad - Small
US$9.25Crispy Chicken Caesar Salad - Large
US$12.12 Wings
Traditional Wings - 10 Pieces
US$12.38Traditional Wings - 20 Pieces
US$23.75Traditional Wings - 40 Pieces
US$45.62Boneless Wings - 10 Pieces
US$12.38Boneless Wings - 20 Pieces
US$23.75Boneless Wings - 40 Pieces
US$45.62 Sandwiches
Fish Sandwich - Sandwich
US$10.25Grilled Chicken Breast Salad - Sandwich
US$10.25Chicken Salad Croissant - Sandwich
US$9.25Grilled Ham & Cheese Sandwich - Sandwich
US$8.50Grilled Cheese Sandwich - Sandwich
US$6.00Submarine - Half
US$7.12Submarine - Whole
US$13.50Stromboli - Half
US$7.12Stromboli - Whole
US$13.50Texas BBQ Sandwich - Half
US$7.12Texas BBQ Sandwich - Whole
US$13.50Baked Ham & Cheese Sandwich - Sandwich
US$7.12Tenderloin Sandwich - King
US$12.00Grilled Tenderloin Sandwich - Sandwich
US$9.50Hamburger - 1/2 Lb.
US$8.25Hamburger - 1/4 Lb.
US$8.25Crispy Chicken Sandwich - Sandwich
US$10.25Chili Dog - Regular
US$6.50 Dinners
Fish Dinner - Dinner
US$12.75Grilled Chicken On Rice - Dinner
US$12.75Grilled Ground Steak - 1/2 Lb.
US$12.75Monterey Burger - Dinner
US$12.75Chicken Dipper Platter - Platter
US$12.75 Mexican Food
Chicken Taco Light - Regular
US$4.00Beef Taco Light - Regular
US$3.75Chicken Soft Taco - Regular
US$4.00Beef Soft Taco - Regular
US$3.75Chicken Taco - Regular
US$3.62Beef Taco - Regular
US$3.38Chicken Burrito - Regular
US$6.62Burrito Supreme - Regular
US$8.25Beef Burrito - Regular
US$6.38 Mexican Dinners
Chicken Tacos - 2 Pieces
US$10.00Beef Tacos - 2 Pieces
US$9.38Chicken Burrito & Taco - Dinner
US$11.75Beef Burrito & Taco - Dinner
US$11.00Burrito Supreme & Taco - Dinner
US$12.75Beans - Dinner
US$4.00Rice - Dinner
US$4.00 Kid's Menu
Kid's Spaghetti - Kids
US$4.62Kid's Hot Dog - Kids
US$7.38Kid's Chicken Dipper - Kids
US$7.38Kid's Grilled Cheese - 1/2
US$7.38